Company

Will getting a second dog help separation anxiety?

Usually not on its own. What the research says about a second dog, how to tell whether company would help your dog, and how to test it before you commit.

By MikeUpdated October 25, 20263 min readHow we source this

Painted illustration: an owner reading on the sofa with the dog resting beside them
Not veterinary advice. We are not veterinarians. Every clinical statement below is attributed to a named study or veterinary body and linked, so you can check it. If your dog is injured, in pain or panicking, contact a vet today.

“Get another dog — they’ll keep each other company.” You’ve probably heard it from friends, family, maybe even a trainer. It’s appealing. It’s also a big commitment to make on a guess.

The short answer: usually not on its own. Whether it’s a second dog or any other pet, having other animals at home isn’t linked to less separation anxiety, and many dogs with separation anxiety need people, not just company. A second dog can help dogs who settle with any company, and you can test for that before you commit.

Does another dog help? What the research says

Why it works for some dogs and not others

If your dog’s distress is about being alone, a companion might help. If it’s about being apart from you, another dog won’t change that (see when one person leaving is the trigger) — and you’ll have two dogs to care for.

How do I know if my dog would benefit from another dog?

Test it before you commit

If you already have two dogs

Having another dog at home doesn’t appear to protect against separation anxiety (Flannigan & Dodman, 2001). If both dogs are distressed, each may need its own plan — a professional’s view is worth having. If one copes and the other doesn’t, practice may need to include separating the dogs from each other for short periods (our rule of thumb).

What reliably helps

The approach with the best evidence isn’t company — it’s teaching your dog that being alone is safe, one short, calm absence at a time (Butler et al., 2011; Sargisson, 2014). Company is still useful while you train: most dogs with separation anxiety are fine as long as someone is with them (ASPCA), so a sitter, friend or daycare can cover long absences.

Choosing a dog? Breed matters less than you might think — see dog breeds with separation anxiety.

Free starter guideFind your dog’s numberThe complete threshold-test chapter, the five rules and the Quick-Start Card. Free PDF.Get the free guide →

Common questions

Does having two dogs help with separation anxiety?

Not reliably. In a study of 400 dogs, having other pets at home was not linked to separation anxiety, and many anxious dogs need people rather than just company. Another dog can help a dog who settles with any company, so test that with a calm dog your dog already likes before you commit.

Are dogs happier with a second dog?

Some are, some aren't — it depends on the dogs. For separation anxiety specifically, having other pets at home was not linked to separation anxiety in a study of 400 dogs, so a second dog isn't a reliable fix.

What if both my dogs are anxious?

Each may need its own plan, and it's worth getting a professional's view. If one copes and the other doesn't, practice may need to include separating the dogs from each other for short periods too.

Would a cat help my dog's separation anxiety?

There's no good evidence that it would. In a study of 400 dogs, having other pets in the home was not linked to separation anxiety either way. If your dog's distress is about being apart from people, another animal is unlikely to change it.

The Seconds to Hours kit

Stop guessing how long to leave your dog.

An 82-page illustrated guide, a fillable workbook, an Excel tracker that tells you what to do after every session, and a one-page card for the fridge. 111 cited sources.